What to Do If You Get a Subpoena: A Comprehensive Guide

1. Understanding the Subpoena

A subpoena is a legal document – issued by a court or other government entity. It compels you to appear and provide testimony or produce documents. Receiving one can feel daunting – but staying calm and informed is key. Let’s break it down.

There are different types of subpoenas:

- -

• Subpoena ad testificandum – requires oral testimony
• Subpoena duces tecum – requires production of documents/evidence

Carefully review the subpoena’s details – as failure to comply can result in civil/criminal penalties. It will specify the date, time, location, and nature of required actions. Don’t ignore it – that’s a surefire way to make matters worse.

Understanding the context is crucial. Was the subpoena issued in a criminal or civil case? Are you a witness, defendant, or third party? Knowing your role – and the potential implications – is the first step. It could be that you simply did not see the bus – and are an innocent bystander called to testify.

The prospect of testifying or providing sensitive information can be nerve-wracking. You may worry about self-incrimination, privacy violations, or retaliation. It’s normal to feel anxious – but don’t panic. With proper guidance, you can navigate this situation while protecting your rights.

Remember, a subpoena is not an accusation of wrongdoing. It’s a legal mechanism to gather information – and your compliance is compulsory. However, you have rights and options – which we’ll explore in the following sections.

- -

If you find the subpoena confusing or have concerns – don’t try to decipher the legalese alone. Consulting an experienced attorney is highly advisable – especially if you’re unsure about your obligations or potential risks.

2. Responding to the Subpoena

Once you understand the subpoena’s nature and context – it’s time to decide how to respond. You have several options, each with its own implications. Let’s explore them:

Comply

The simplest route is to comply fully – appear as summoned and provide the requested testimony/documents. This avoids any potential legal repercussions for non-compliance. However, it may not be the best choice – if you have valid concerns or objections.

Negotiate

You can try negotiating the subpoena’s terms with the issuing party. For example, you could request:

• Narrowing the scope of requested documents
• Extending deadlines for more preparation time
• Changing the date/location for convenience

Negotiation requires tact and legal expertise – so consulting an attorney is wise.

- -

Object

If you believe the subpoena is improper, overly broad, or infringes on your rights – you can file a motion to quash (revoke) or modify it. Common grounds for objection include:

• Subpoena was improperly issued/lacks jurisdiction
• Requests are irrelevant to the case
• Compliance would be unduly burdensome
• Privileged information (e.g. attorney-client) is sought

Objections must be filed within the specified timeframe and follow proper procedures – making legal counsel essential.

Your chosen response depends on various factors – including the subpoena’s scope, your role in the case, and potential risks of non-compliance or providing certain information. Weigh your options carefully – as each path has consequences.

- -

For example, if you’re a third-party witness with no stakes in the case – full compliance may be the simplest solution. But if you’re a defendant or key witness – and the subpoena requests potentially incriminating evidence – objecting or negotiating could be prudent.

Remember, ignoring a subpoena is ill-advised – as it could lead to civil/criminal contempt charges. Even if you object, appear on the specified date to argue your position before the court. Failure to respond altogether is never an option.

3. Hiring an Attorney

While not legally required – retaining an experienced attorney is highly recommended when dealing with a subpoena. An attorney can provide invaluable guidance and representation, including:

Reviewing the Subpoena

An attorney can thoroughly analyze the subpoena’s validity, scope, and legal implications – spotting potential issues you may overlook.

Advising on Your Rights

They’ll ensure you understand your rights and obligations – such as invoking privileges like attorney-client confidentiality or the Fifth Amendment protection against self-incrimination.

Negotiating or Objecting

If negotiation or objection is warranted, an attorney can skillfully argue for modifying or quashing the subpoena on your behalf – following proper procedures and increasing your chances of success.

Preparing for Testimony

If you must testify, an attorney can help you prepare – ensuring you understand questioning strategies, know what information to provide or withhold, and avoid inadvertently harming your case.

Representing You in Court

Should disputes or contempt proceedings arise from the subpoena, an attorney can provide robust legal representation and advocacy to protect your interests.

The costs of hiring an attorney may seem daunting – but the potential risks of mishandling a subpoena often outweigh the expense. From inadvertent self-incrimination to contempt charges, the consequences can be severe.

If hiring private counsel is financially prohibitive – you may qualify for a court-appointed attorney or pro bono legal aid, depending on your circumstances. Explore all options – as navigating this process without legal guidance is highly inadvisable.

Here’s a table summarizing key reasons to hire an attorney for subpoena matters:

While the decision is ultimately yours, most legal experts advise against representing yourself in subpoena matters – unless you have extensive legal training and experience in the relevant area of law.

4. Privileged Information and Self-Incrimination Concerns

Two major concerns when dealing with subpoenas are protecting privileged information and avoiding self-incrimination. An attorney can guide you through properly addressing these issues – but it’s wise to understand the core concepts.

Privileged Information

Certain communications are deemed “privileged” and protected from forced disclosure, including:

• Attorney-client communications
• Spousal communications
• Doctor-patient conversations
• Confidential journalistic sources

If a subpoena seeks privileged information – you can object and refuse to provide it, with proper legal justification.

The Fifth Amendment Right Against Self-Incrimination

The Fifth Amendment allows you to refuse to testify or provide information that could be directly or indirectly used to incriminate you in a crime. However, invoking this