The Pros and Cons of Business Bankruptcy vs. Debt Settlement

An Overview of Business Bankruptcy

Business bankruptcy is a legal process governed by federal law that provides businesses relief from overwhelming debts. The most common types of bankruptcy filings for businesses are Chapter 7 and Chapter 11.

In a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, the business stops operating and a trustee is appointed to liquidate the company’s assets to pay creditors. Any debts remaining after the assets are distributed are discharged, providing the business with a fresh start. Chapter 7 bankruptcy typically takes 3-6 months to complete.

- -

With Chapter 11 bankruptcy, the business continues operating and works on a court-approved reorganization plan to repay creditors over time. Existing management usually remains in place unless there are allegations of fraud or incompetence. The reorganization plan allows the business to restructure debts and emerge from bankruptcy as a viable entity. Chapter 11 cases can take anywhere from 6 months to multiple years.

Pros of Business Bankruptcy

• Immediate relief from creditors: Upon filing, an automatic stay goes into effect stopping collections, foreclosures, and repossessions. This provides breathing room to reorganize.
• Ability to cancel contracts: Certain undesirable contracts and leases can be rejected in bankruptcy. This allows focusing resources on more profitable ventures.
• Protection for owners: Personal assets of owners are usually exempt from business bankruptcy proceedings.
• Increased chances of survival: The reorganization process can help position the business for future success.
• Debt discharge: For Chapter 7, qualifying business debts not paid by liquidated assets are erased.

Cons of Business Bankruptcy

• High legal fees: Attorney and court costs for Chapter 11 bankruptcy often exceed $100,000. Chapter 7 is less but still involves substantial legal fees.
• Trustee oversight: A court-appointed trustee monitors the company’s finances and operations throughout the process.
• Public records: Bankruptcy filings become part of public record, damaging the business’s reputation.
• No guarantees: Reorganization could still fail, leading to liquidation.
• Limited control: Major decisions need court approval, limiting management’s autonomy.
• Creditor pressure: Creditors can request conversion from Chapter 11 to Chapter 7 forcing liquidation.

An Overview of Debt Settlement

Debt settlement, also called debt negotiation or arbitration, is an informal agreement between a business and creditors to settle on reduced balances. A neutral third-party negotiator is often hired to work out a deal.

The process starts by the business stopping payments to creditors. With accounts delinquent, the negotiator contacts creditors and tries securing a lump-sum settlement for a portion of the balance (typically 40-60%). The settlement agreement stipulates that the remaining amount is forgiven.

A business should have the lump sums ready because settlements need to be funded quickly once terms are reached. The entire process may take anywhere from 6 months to several years depending on the creditor, balances, and negotiator.

- -

Pros of Debt Settlement

• Avoids bankruptcy: Settling debts informally prevents the need to file bankruptcy.
• Lower balances: Creditors agree to reduced payoffs, decreasing amount owed.
• Pay on own terms: Business has flexibility in funding settlements when able.
• Prevents collections: Accounts stay with original creditors avoiding collection agency costs.
• Private process: Debt settlement happens out of court without public records.
• Business continues operating: Avoiding bankruptcy allows continuing normal operations.

Cons of Debt Settlement

• Damaged credit: Accounts become delinquent and show as defaults, harming credit score.
• High fees: Settlement companies often charge 15-25% of enrolled debt.
• Tax implications: Settled debt may be considered taxable income by the IRS.
• No guarantee: Creditors can refuse to settle and continue collections.
• Balloon payments: Settlements require large lump-sum payments, which can be difficult to fund.
• Ongoing collections: Accounts stay in collections until settlement is reached.
• Lawsuits possible: Creditors may sue for full balances despite settlement efforts.

Key Differences Between the Options

When it comes to choosing between bankruptcy and debt settlement, there are a few key differences to keep in mind:

• Cost: Bankruptcy has court and legal fees while settlement has company fees. Overall, bankruptcy tends to cost more.
• Credit impact: Bankruptcy damages credit for 10 years. Settlement damages credit but less severely as accounts get closed.
• Timeframe: Bankruptcy provides faster relief, typically within months. Settlement can take several years to finalize negotiations.
• Operations: Bankruptcy may force liquidation shutting down operations. Settlement allows continuing business as usual.
• Certainty: Court-ordered bankruptcy delivers an assured outcome. Settlement relies on voluntary creditor cooperation.
• Cancellation: Bankruptcy cancels eligible debts. Settlements lead to reduced balances that need repayment.

Which Option is Right for Your Business?

There are several factors to help determine if bankruptcy or debt settlement better fits your situation.

Bankruptcy may be preferable if your business:

• Needs immediate protection from creditors
• Has debts unlikely to be settled voluntarily
• Is facing lawsuits or foreclosure actions
• Qualifies for full debt discharge under Chapter 7
• Can successfully reorganize under Chapter 11

Debt settlement may be better if your business:

• Wants to avoid the stigma of bankruptcy
• Has the ability to fund lump-sum settlements
• Has creditors willing to negotiate reduced balances
• Is facing lower debt loads more amenable to settling
• Wants to retain full control and keep operating

Every business’s circumstances are unique, so it’s smart to consult qualified legal and financial advisors before deciding on the best debt relief strategy. But understanding the pros and cons of bankruptcy and debt settlement establishes a helpful framework for making this major financial decision.

- -